Bethlehem, Northampton and Lehigh Counties

Plaster repair in Bethlehem, PA.

About ten thousand Bethlehem homes predate 1940, and their plaster runs from lime in the oldest brick and stone houses to the gypsum of the 1920s. How it fails depends on the house's age and what its walls are made of.

A period dining room with white walls, a dark wood corner cabinet, and a doorway looking through to the staircase.
A period dining room in white.

Plaster repair for Bethlehem homes

Roughly a third of Bethlehem's homes, about ten thousand houses, were built before 1940, while plaster was still the standard wall. Another quarter went up between 1940 and 1959, as drywall was taking over, and some of those have plaster too, usually two coats over gypsum lath rather than three over wood.

The older houses divide by side of the river. North of the Lehigh, the historic district's buildings run from the mid-1700s into the early 1900s; to the south, brick row homes went up for families living on mill pay; on the West Side, twins and the large houses of Mount Airy came between about 1895 and 1930. Each puts its plaster on a different wall and wears it differently.

Bethlehem

North Side masonry, South Side party walls, Mount Airy ceilings

The Central Bethlehem Historic District is mostly two-and-a-half-story brick and stone, and in buildings that old the plaster on outside walls was often laid directly against the masonry. It lasts as long as the wall can dry, so a tide line of staining near the floor, or paint that blisters under a window, is read as a moisture question before a plaster one.

South of the river, rows built close together share brick party walls, and plaster on a party wall answers to two foundations. Mount Airy's large houses date mostly from 1910 to 1930, when gypsum plaster, and increasingly gypsum lath, had replaced lime and wood. In rooms that size a ceiling crack can run the full width; if the plaster on both sides is still attached and dry, it is cosmetic and can be bridged rather than taken down.

A stripped period wall of failing plaster, patched in places, with a bucket and loose paper on the floor.
Before: a period wall stripped back to failing plaster.

Worth knowing

  1. Generations of patches

    Plaster in the Historic District's older houses has usually been patched in several eras and materials, which shrink and take paint differently. Tying them together under one finish is what stops the old outlines from showing through.

  2. Fountain Hill, same questions

    Next door, more than four in ten Fountain Hill homes predate 1940, so the plaster questions of the city's older blocks carry across the borough line.

  3. The township is newer

    About two-thirds of Bethlehem Township's homes were built in 1980 or later. There, a cracked wall is usually drywall, and so is the repair.

The work

How the work goes

The same care on every job, in every town. The full guide to plaster repair.

A period foyer and staircase mid-renovation, the floor strewn with stripped material and a painter at work.
Before: a period foyer mid-renovation.
  1. Find the cause

    Every repair starts with why the plaster failed: a leak, a settling corner, a ceiling carrying too much. Randy walks the rooms with you, and the walkthrough and written estimate are complimentary.

  2. Reattach what’s loose

    Plaster that has lost its keys but is otherwise sound can be drawn back to the lath with screws and broad plaster washers. It doesn’t have to come down.

  3. Bridge the cracks

    Cracks are opened slightly, bridged with fiberglass mesh tape and filled with setting-type compound, which hardens by chemical reaction and shrinks less than ordinary joint compound. A finer compound goes on last, because setting compound is hard to sand.

  4. Rebuild what’s missing

    Where plaster is gone down to the lath, the old edges get a bonding agent and the hole is built back up in layers, each stepped over the last. Larger openings can take a piece of board shimmed to the plaster’s thickness instead.

  5. Finish to the wall around it

    The repair is feathered into the old surface, or the whole wall is skimmed so old and new read as one. On a wavy old wall, the patch follows the wall’s contour; a dead-flat patch would stand out.

Questions

Plaster repair, Bethlehem.

Does HARB need to approve plaster repairs in a Central Bethlehem Historic District house?

No. The Historical and Architectural Review Board reviews exterior changes that can be seen from a public way, paint colors included, and plaster inside the house is not one of them. If the repair goes with outside work, such as repointing or a new color, that part goes to the board, so check with the city before it starts.

The crack in our South Side row home runs where the party wall meets the front wall. Is that structural?

It can be, which is why a crack where two walls meet gets a closer look than one in the middle of a wall. A fine line that stays put is often two houses settling slightly differently over the years, and it is bridged and finished like any crack. One that keeps widening, or comes with sloping floors or sticking doors, should be seen by a structural engineer before it is patched.

We're renovating a West Side twin. Is it better to strip the plaster to the studs?

Only where it has failed. Sound plaster keeps the depth the original casings and baseboards were set to, and stripping it means resetting all of that trim, plus the dust and noise of demolition beside the other half of the twin. Sections ruined by a long leak, or broadly detached from the lath, are the ones to replace.

Consultation

Request a private consultation.

Private walkthrough & written estimate, complimentary. Tell us a little about the house and the rooms, and Randy will be in touch to arrange a time.

Hours
Monday – Friday8:30 AM – 5:30 PMSaturday10 AM – 3 PMSundayClosed
Service area
Easton, Bethlehem, Allentown and the greater Lehigh Valley; Bucks County, Pennsylvania.

Fully insured — proof on request. Residential and commercial.

Randy’sPainting & DrywallReply card
The project
Preferred contact

Walkthrough & written estimate, complimentary.